← Front page
From the EditorsDirigo Report · November 6, 2026

The Price of a Swing Vote

Susan Collins built Maine's leverage by being the vote no party could count on. In the age of Trump, the question is whether a check on him is worth more than what that leverage brought home.

Susan Collins always backed whoever held the cards on big votes, Democrat or Republican, because that's how she built her power and brought home the money. Maine senators (and senators from other small states) have been running that exact playbook for decades; Olympia Snowe did the same thing.

People have short memories, but the national GOP hated her guts during the Obama years. When she provided the swing vote to pass the 2009 stimulus, backed Obama's Supreme Court picks, and later broke ranks to save the ACA, conservative talk radio treated her like she was the root of all evil. But she didn't cross the aisle out of charity. She made party leadership pay up. Every time she held the deciding vote, she leveraged it for defense contracts at Bath Iron Works, grants for rural hospitals, and federal earmarks Maine could never afford on its own tax base.

We're a small state with two House seats. We have zero raw political weight in Washington unless we have an unpredictable swing vote sitting near the top of the Appropriations Committee. The second party leaders know they can take your vote for granted, they stop offering you a dime.

It's completely transactional, and it disgusts voters on both sides because it treats fundamental issues like an auction block rather than a matter of principle. But trading that leverage for an ideological purist who toes the party line 99% of the time means Maine goes straight to the back of the committee line. Let's just be real about that.

But this is the age of Trump. His corruption and moral degradation have to be stopped...and having an automatic vote to put the brakes on Trump probably matters more than whatever funding we're about to lose. We'll see.

From the Editors is signed opinion from Dirigo Report. It is separate from the front page, which is an automated, nonpartisan board of links to original Maine reporting. The views here are the editors' own.

More from the Editors →